In this study, preterm infants with severe IVH were retrospectively reviewed and evaluated for some points of neurodevelopmental outcome. It was found that the incidence of severe IVH, compared with previously published studies, remained relatively high, and that severity of IVH is associated with an increased risk of death, the development of PHVD and unfavorable motor outcome. Additionally, early RBC transfusion in infants with severe IVH seems to be associated with either death or severe motor disability in those survived.
In this study, the overall incidence of severe IVH among VLBW admissions to the unit was 8.5 %, which is comparable with many studies published over the past two decades 3,20-22, but remains slightly higher than the rate of 5-7% in high-income countries 2,23, indicating a need for better implementation of optimal care guidelines.
Despite factors related to degree of immaturity or indicating a critical clinical course after birth seemed to be associated with early death, the patients demonstrate a dependency of survival on IVH severity and RBC transfusion within the first days of life. The finding of low survival in infants with PVHI has also been highlighted in previous studies 26,28. Although it was an expected finding, the association of early RBC transfusion with the mortality may be an indication of the extent of the hemorrhage, which can be either intra-parenchymal or bilaterally intra-ventricular, in the absence of possible other comorbidities such as pulmonary hemorrhage. This high rate of mortality can be explained by that in the presence of extensive hemorrhage, which described previously as PVHI severity score and predicts a very poor outcome with multiple disabilities 28,29, and on the request of the parents, many centers may prefer to withdraw intensive care treatment or at least perform no heroic measures to resuscitate the infant, despite debatable the legal and ethical considerations 3,27.
In this series, two-thirds of the surviving infants at three weeks of life developed PHVD requiring any form of intervention. This rate is consistent with some previous reports 10,26,27,30, though reports with lower rate have also been described 22,24,25,31. The association between severity of IVH and the risk for developing PHVD in this study has also been reported by previous studies 3,26,31-33. Despite lumbar puncture was initially performed in all patients here, the subsequent intervention varied depending on the patient's clinical condition, individual surgeon preference of technique, the availability of VAD and the affordability of VAD by the parents. VAD and VSG shunt are the most commonly used temporizing measures 9, whereas later has not been performed at our center due to neurosurgeon preference. In infants treated with VAD, the results presented herein are consisted with the rates of VP shunt requirement, device infection, and other complications in which reported by other studies 9,10,25,30,34. Despite the infection rate from serial tapping of reservoir has ranged from 0 to 22%, employing infection control measures during both surgical implantation of the reservoirs and reservoir tapping provide controlled removal of CSF over a prolonged period 30,35,36. In this series, the rates of infection and revision of VPS following a temporizing intervention was lower in VAD subgroup when compared to other options. It has been reported that delaying VPS conversion, when compared to earlier, is associated with low infection and revision rate of subsequent VP shunting and better neurodevelopmental outcome 37,38. Therefore, using VAD as a temporization technique, is able to allow delaying VP shunting for a long period of time.
In the subgroup of infants treated with only serial punctures, mortality was higher due to severe clinical condition of the infants. The aim of early VPS insertion in the stable ones was to avoid further lumbar or ventricular punctures, which both are not recommended as the mainstay treatment due to high risk of the failure to remove sufficient quantities of CSF, infection and parenchymal injury 5,6. Unfortunately, both methods are still widely used in some centers 11. EVD has been used an alternative option to serial lumbar or ventricular punctures, or when other primary temporizing measures have failed. Despite the rate of permanent VP shunt placement after an EVD has been proposed to be lower when compared to other options 6,39, EVD has fallen out of favor due to both higher risk of infection and nursing care difficulties 5-7,40.
In this study, the mean age of infants at first intervention is comparable to most previous studies 8,24, but higher than those in the studies objecting to assess the effects of early intervention 41,42. It has been reported that older age at temporizing neurosurgical procedure is associated with the increased risk of conversion to VPS and neurodevelopmental impairment 8. Despite the timing and definitive criteria of the first intervention are still a matter of debate, the ventricular measurements based on ultrasound appear rational to help in determining the optimal time of early intervention, as to prevent the hazardous effects of hydrocephalic state and blood products on the developing brain 7,41,43.
In this series, the rate of a permanent VP insertion following a temporary intervention was comparable with previous studies, in which it has been reported as ranging between 25% and 95% 25,30,33,34,37,41,44. However, in the recent randomized controlled trial it has been reported as low as 19%, which is the lowest in the literature 42, presumably thanks to very early intervention. Conversely, VP shunt conversion rates have been reported to be higher if initial intervention was not commenced until the onset of clinical signs 37,41. Growing evidence has shown that intervention at early stage, based on ventricular measurements using ultrasound, prior to development of clinical symptoms and severe dilation of the lateral ventricles, is associated with lower rates of VP shunting and favorable neurodevelopmental outcomes, even when a VP shunt is eventually needed 8,29,41,42. However, choice of temporization techniques, particularly VAD and VGS, does not appear to influence rates of conversion to permanent ventricular CSF diversion, infection, obstruction, subsequent shunt infection, mortality, long-term disability 8-10,44.
Overall, in this series, considering motor outcomes at 18 to 22 months' corrected age, 55% of the patients had varying degrees of motor disability, in which GMFCS score was ≥ 2. This rate is comparable to previous studies 10,26,27,29,41,43, in which CP rates have been reported from 23% to 91% in infants with severe IVH. Despite in multivariate analyses nothing was significantly associated to motor disability, due to probably small sample size of the study, the severe motor disability appears to be predicted by early RBC transfusion and permanent VP shunt. Some studies have reported that worse outcome was associated with the severity of IVH, in particular when complicated by PHVD requiring neurosurgical intervention 3,4,43, whereas early control of ventricular dilation may provide better results 41,42, suggesting to avoid large degrees of ventricular dilation. The finding of that the association of early RBC transfusion with severe motor outcome may be explained by that severe drop in hemoglobin level requiring RBC transfusion may indirectly be an indication of the extent of the hemorrhage or the burden of extracellular hemoglobin to which the developing brain is exposed, which all eventually contribute to neurodevelopmental disability. Although not statistically significant in this series, recurrent shunt dysfunctions may also affect neurodevelopmental outcome by causing recurrent rapid increase in ICP 43.
There were some limitations in this study, in which database only contained infants with severe IVH. Therefore, the results are not generalizable to the population of all preterm infants. Given the retrospective nature of the study, the data may not have included some necessary variables which can contribute to various outcomes (such as periventricular leukomalacia). The single-center character, with a relatively small patient cohort and substantial heterogeneity in the option for management, and a high rate of loss to follow-up reduced statistical power. Additionally, other components of neurodevelopmental outcome could not be assessed due to various reasons. Despite these limitations, the study was conducted in a geographic area, where no comprehensive relevant data available, and included the 6-year experience of a center in respect to the various outcomes in small preterm infants with severe IVH.